One of my readers suggested that I tackle the topic of engagement rings, which I absolutely would love to talk about. I have a feeling this will be the first of a few posts where I write about rings and engagement. I am not going to go into the whole dealie about proposals YET, but we will definitely get there soon. (Warning: My feelings on this are not “traditional,” but neither are a lot of things you probably thought were traditional about weddings…)
It’s All About Options
So, if you’re a tomboy bride*, the good news is that you don’t have to get engaged like “everyone else”. If you grew up in my generation, you have been inundated with ads and movies and magazines telling you over and over again that a diamond is the clear sign of True Love, and nothing else is up to snuff. “A Diamond Is Forever” and all that jazz. Some of us can’t hear certain instrumental music pieces without imagining shadow-people dancing together…such is the power of advertising.
Well, DeBeers would be horrified to hear that I’m telling you people this, but receiving a diamond engagement ring is not, in fact, some centuries-old tradition that you must adhere to in order to be really in love. The “tradition” of giving diamond engagement rings only really took off a little more than 100 years ago. That’s a really short time compared to the long history of marriage, and even shorter when you consider the history of human love. We’re going on just 100 measly years of “tradition”. Even then, it was all part of a sales tactic by the diamond industry, much like the new right-hand rings and anniversary rings are being touted now.
The tradition of giving a ring as a sign of betrothal is quite older than that, though, so feel free to stick to the rings category if tradition is your thing. I’ve seen varying reports, but most agree that betrothal rings became popular in either the 13th or 14th century. Later, women were often given rings with their birthstone in it or given a completely different type of jewelry as a sign of engagement.
So already you’ve got a bunch of options — You can get a diamond ring, a non-diamond ring, a brooch, a necklace, a big ole Mr. T style chain that says “He’s Mine”… whatever you want!
You could also, gasp, not wear anything at all to signify you are engaged. If jewelry is not your thing, and you are not concerned with everyone knowing your “status” immediately upon glancing at your left hand, you don’t have to do it.
What We Did
I think diamond rings are pretty, but I had icky feelings about getting a new diamond for our engagement because of controversy surrounding the diamond industry, so our first step was to look for vintage and antique rings and find out what kind of style I liked.
We communicated a lot about this, because just as Greg does not expect me to be a traditional gal, I do not expect him to know a whole lot about buying women’s jewelry. I thought it would be unfair to toss him into the wilds of jewelry shopping with no hints as to what type of stuff I liked…and it would have sucked for me to have to wear a ring I didn’t particularly like every day for a long while, too.
When we actually did get engaged, Greg gave me his mother’s engagement ring. Here’s a picture of it (and also of a hair or fuzz or something that was apparently stuck to it) :

This was so special to me, because we had just decided to move into her old house at the time. It’s also wonderful to feel like she is with me in some way as we plan the wedding.
The other thing is that Greg also wears an engagement ring. It’s just a plain band, very simple, but we both have something on our left ring fingers to signify that we are committed to each other. I joked that if I had to look “taken,” so should he!
So Where Do You Start?
I guess my main point of advice is to think about what you like, and what you feel would represent your engagement. And talk to your partner about it — I hope you are talking about getting engaged at least a little bit before actually doing it — so that he or she knows what your preferences are.
There are some awesome stores online and on Etsy that feature some handmade, vintage, non-traditional, and otherwise super-cool rings. I recommend checking them out for ideas. Here are a couple of places to look for handmade & “green” rings:
Artisan Look
Bario-Neal Jewelry
Beth Cyr Jewelry
Barbara Michelle Jacobs
Also check out vintage/antique jewelry auctions, Ebay, etc… there are some real finds there.

*To see my definition of Tomboy Bride, check out the first TBB post over here!